Protests Erupt Over Sijena Murals During Aragon Team's Inspection Process
In a cultural standoff, the National Art Museum of Catalonia (MNAC) in Barcelona has delayed the transfer of a set of 13th-century Romanesque murals to the Sijena Monastery in Huesca, Aragon. The museum's decision stems from concerns about the fragility of the murals and doubts over their survival during the relocation process [1].
The controversy reached a new height on Monday morning, as a protest took place outside the MNAC, organized by the Catalan National Assembly. The protest was joined by figures such as former Catalan president Laura Borràs and ANC president Lluís Llach. The protesters chanted slogans like "It's not justice, it's a plunder." The gathering attracted fewer than 50 demonstrators [1].
The court order to return the murals was made by Spain's Supreme Court, concluding more than a decade of litigation over the Romanesque masterpieces. The artworks, painted around 1200, are considered a monumental example of medieval Hispanic art, blending Old and New Testament scenes with Byzantine and English Romanesque influences [1].
MNAC has submitted filings warning the court of the risks and is expected to formally contest the execution order on conservation grounds. The museum officials remain adamant that relocating the more delicate frescoes, especially those salvaged from the chapter house, could cause irreversible damage. In a proposed phased approach, MNAC suggests beginning with the sturdier works that were removed from the Sijena Monastery in the 1960s [1].
Meanwhile, the Aragonese team, led by restorer Natalia Martínez de Pisón, has entered the museum discreetly through a side entrance. They began their work on the less fragile so-called profane murals, marking a significant step in enforcing the controversial ruling [1].
The fate of the core murals, already mounted, reconstructed, and climate-protected, remains uncertain, caught between the judicial mandate and the limits of preservation. The inspection of the murals will continue through Wednesday, using photogrammetry to assess their condition and viability for transport [1].
This bitter legal and cultural battle reflects ongoing tensions between the MNAC and the Government of Aragon. As the standoff continues, both sides remain steadfast in their positions, with the future of these priceless works of art hanging in the balance.
[1] Sources: Catalan News Agency, El Pais, The Art Newspaper, BBC News.
- The upcoming exhibition of the 13th-century Romanesque murals at the Sijena Monastery could be impacted by the ongoing war-and-conflicts between the National Art Museum of Catalonia (MNAC) and the Government of Aragon.
- As political tensions rise, cultural-travel enthusiasts may find the controversy surrounding these medieval artworks featured in general-news headlines, potentially discouraging visits to Spain's museums and historical sites.
- While internal discussions and legal battles ensue, many are monitoring the situation closely, as the maintenance and protection of these priceless art pieces are crucial for understanding the evolution of medieval Hispanic art and its intertwining influences.
- This dispute, not only a conflict of politics but also a standoff in the world of art, raises questions about the responsibility museums have towards preserving cultural heritage and the role they play in shaping the lifestyle and perceptions of the broader public.
